Statutory Warranties SA: Builder’s Warranty, Defects and the Five-Year Limit
Statutory warranties for building work in South Australia
Statutory warranties are implied by section 32 of the Building Work Contractors Act 1995 (SA) into every domestic building work contract in South Australia, including jobs under $20,000. They cover proper work, good materials, legal compliance, diligence, habitability and fitness for purpose. They pass to later owners of the house, and they cannot be excluded. Claims must be started within five years after the work is completed. Talon Legal advises builders, trades and owners on warranty and defect claims. Book a same-day free 30-minute consultation or call (08) 7094 2021.
Statutory warranties SA key facts
| Issue | Position in South Australia |
|---|---|
| Governing law | Sections 32, 37, 38, 40 and 42 of the Building Work Contractors Act 1995 (SA). Current to 20 November 2026. |
| Which contracts | Every domestic building work contract entered into on or after 22 January 1987, including minor domestic building work (section 32(1), (2)). |
| The six warranties | Proper work to accepted trade standards and the agreed plans and specifications; good and proper materials; compliance with all statutory requirements; reasonable diligence where no completion period is stipulated; a new house reasonably fit for human habitation; fitness for a purpose the owner made known (section 32(2)). |
| Who benefits | The building owner, a person who later buys or acquires the house (section 32(3)), and a person who buys a house from the contractor who built it (section 32(4)). |
| Time limit | Proceedings must be commenced within five years after completion of the building work, and the period cannot be extended (section 32(5), (6)). |
| The 10-year planning law limit | Does not displace the five-year limit (Duncan v Bert Farina Constructions Pty Ltd [2024] SASCA 67 at [3]). |
| Contracting out | Any exclusion, limitation, modification or waiver of the warranties is void (section 42). |
| Builder's defence | Deficiencies that arose from instructions the owner insisted on contrary to the contractor's written advice (section 32(7)). |
| Where claims go | The Magistrates Court, where the dispute involves whether the building work was performed in accordance with the contract (section 37(2), (3)). |
| Orders | Remedial work, an order to employ a licensed contractor to do it, payment or compensation, and a certificate that the work was done properly (section 37(6) to (8)). |
| Ignoring a remedial order | An offence, with a maximum fine of $50,000 for an individual or $250,000 for a company, and compensation (section 37(9)). |
| Large claims | Claims over $100,000 can be referred to the District Court (section 40). |
| First step | Same-day free 30-minute consultation. Call (08) 7094 2021. |
Need advice on a defect claim? What this guide covers
This guide explains the statutory warranties on South Australian building work: what they cover, who can enforce them, how long they last and how defect claims are decided, current to 20 November 2026. It is part of our trade contracts SA guides, alongside domestic building work contracts, minor domestic building work and variations.
We act for builders and trades responding to defect claims, and we draft the defect and handover clauses that keep warranty disputes short.
Free Consultation. Send us the contract, the defect list and any reports before you respond. Book a same-day free 30-minute consultation or call (08) 7094 2021.
On this page
- What are the statutory warranties?
- Which contracts carry the warranties?
- Who can claim under the warranties?
- How long is a builder's warranty in SA?
- Can a builder exclude or limit the warranties?
- What defences does a builder have?
- Where are defect claims heard and what can the court order?
- How does building indemnity insurance fit?
- How should a contract deal with defects?
- How similar matters tend to play out
- How we act on warranty and defect claims
- Statutory warranty case law
- Frequently asked questions
- Related trade contract guides
What are the statutory warranties?
Section 32(2) of the Building Work Contractors Act 1995 (SA) implies six warranties on the part of the building work contractor in every domestic building work contract.
| Warranty | Section 32(2) | What it means on site |
|---|---|---|
| The building work will be performed in a proper manner to accepted trade standards and in accordance with the plans and specifications agreed to by the parties | (a) | Two tests in one: trade standard workmanship, and conformity with what was agreed. Work can be neat and still breach the warranty if it departs from the specification. |
| All materials supplied by the contractor for use in the work will be good and proper | (b) | Covers the contractor's own materials, not materials the owner supplies. |
| The work will be performed in accordance with all statutory requirements | (c) | Building rules, approvals and conditions, and the technical regulation of the trade's own work. |
| If the contract does not stipulate a completion period, the work will be performed with reasonable diligence | (d) | Applies only where there is no completion period; a contract with a completion date is governed by its own terms on time. |
| If the work is the construction of a house, the house will be reasonably fit for human habitation | (e) | New houses only. |
| If the owner expressly made known the particular purpose of the work, or the result the owner wants, so as to show reliance on the contractor's skill and judgment, the work and materials will be reasonably fit for that purpose or of a nature and quality that might reasonably be expected to achieve that result | (f) | Triggered by what the owner says and relies on. A quote that is silent about purpose does not prevent it arising. |
The warranties are on the part of the building work contractor, the party to the domestic building work contract. A builder that subcontracts the work still gives the warranties to the owner.
Which contracts carry the warranties?
Section 32 applies to contracts entered into on or after 22 January 1987 (section 32(1)), and the warranties are implied in “every domestic building work contract” (section 32(2)). Three consequences follow from where section 32 sits in the Act.
Minor work is included. Section 32 is in Division 2 of Part 5. The exclusion for minor domestic building work in section 27(2) applies only to Division 1, so a $3,000 job carries the same six warranties as a new home.
Regulation exemptions leave the warranties in place. The Building Work Contractors Regulations 2026 take demolition-only contracts out of Divisions 1, 3 and 4 (regulation 5(8)), and contracts with public company owners out of sections 28 to 30 and Division 4 (regulation 5(10)(b)). Neither touches Division 2.
Subcontracts are different. A subcontract for the performance of domestic building work is not a domestic building work contract (section 3), so on a plain reading the section 32 warranties are implied in the builder’s contract with the owner, not in the subcontract. The subcontractor’s exposure to the builder comes from the subcontract’s own terms, and a dispute under a subcontract can be joined with the owner’s proceedings in the Magistrates Court where it involves whether the subcontracted work was performed in accordance with the subcontract (section 37(4), (5)).
Calling the contract something else does not avoid section 32. In Forlyle Pty Ltd v Tiver [2007] SASC 464 the Full Court agreed that a development agreement to have a house built was a domestic building work contract, so the warranties were implied into it ([3]).
Who can claim under the warranties?
The building owner can, and so can later owners. A person who has purchased or otherwise acquired a house succeeds to the rights of the predecessor in title in respect of statutory warranties (section 32(3)). A person who buys a house from the building work contractor who did the work has rights as if the house had been bought from a third party for whom the vendor had done the work under a contract subject to the warranties (section 32(4)).
Section 37(2) gives the right to apply to the Magistrates Court to a party to the domestic building work contract or a person entitled to the benefit of a statutory warranty. A buyer of a five-year-old house can therefore bring a warranty claim against the original builder, within the time limit.
How long is a builder’s warranty in SA?
Proceedings for breach of a statutory warranty must be commenced within five years after completion of the building work to which the proceedings relate (section 32(5)). The period of limitation may not be extended (section 32(6)).
Owners have argued that the 10-year limit for building claims in the planning legislation gives them longer. The Court of Appeal rejected that argument in Duncan v Bert Farina Constructions Pty Ltd [2024] SASCA 67. Section 73 of the Development Act 1993, and its successor section 159 of the Planning, Development and Infrastructure Act 2016, operate only as a 10-year “long stop” on claims for economic loss or rectification costs from defective building work; they do not authorise claims at any time up to 10 years, there is no inconsistency with the five-year limit, and where both apply a respondent may rely on the shorter period ([3]). The owners’ appeal was dismissed ([141]).
Two practical points follow. The five years run from completion of the building work the claim is about, so the completion date matters and should be recorded at handover. And the Court of Appeal’s decision concerned claims relying on the section 32 warranties; a claim on a different footing, such as negligence, raises its own limitation questions.
Can a builder exclude or limit the warranties?
No. Section 42 provides that any purported exclusion, limitation, modification or waiver of a right conferred, or a contractual condition or warranty implied, by the Act is void.
That catches the familiar clauses: “all warranties are limited to 12 months from handover”, “the builder’s liability for defects is limited to the contract price”, “the owner accepts the work as is”, and “the owner waives all claims on practical completion”. Each is void to the extent it cuts down the section 32 warranties.
It also catches settlements. In Forlyle Pty Ltd v Tiver, owners and a builder resolved a defects arbitration with a mutual release of all claims “known or unknown”. The Full Court held that a compromise by which a building owner agrees not to claim for future defects is an exclusion of the statutory warranties and also a limitation, modification or waiver of them, and that the release was void to that extent ([19]); the words “or unknown” were severed and the rest of the settlement was enforced ([24]). A settlement of known defects is valid. A release of defects not yet known is not.
What defences does a builder have?
The Act gives one specific defence. In proceedings for breach of a statutory warranty, it is a defence for the defendant to prove that the deficiencies complained of arose from instructions insisted on by the building owner contrary to the defendant’s advice in writing (section 32(7)). Both elements need proof: insistence by the owner, and advice in writing from the contractor.
Beyond that, a claim is answered on its facts and on the time limit:
- whether the work in fact falls short of accepted trade standards or the agreed plans and specifications;
- whether the materials complained of were supplied by the contractor or by the owner (section 32(2)(b) covers the contractor’s materials);
- whether a fitness for purpose warranty arose at all, which needs a purpose or result expressly made known and reliance on the contractor’s skill and judgment (section 32(2)(f));
- whether proceedings were commenced within five years after completion (section 32(5)).
Where are defect claims heard and what can the court order?
Section 37 gives the Magistrates Court a special jurisdiction over domestic building work. A party to a domestic building work contract, or a person entitled to the benefit of a statutory warranty, can apply for the determination of a dispute arising out of the contract or the performance of the building work to which the warranty relates (section 37(2)). An application about a dispute arising out of a domestic building work contract must involve some question of whether building work has been performed in accordance with the contract (section 37(3)).
| Order | Provision |
|---|---|
| Remedial work, to the extent it is practicable for the breach to be remedied by building work | Section 37(6)(a) |
| Payment of an amount due under the contract, or compensation for the breach | Section 37(6)(b) |
| The person to do the remedial work within a set time, or, if the Court thinks the person is not likely to do it properly, to employ a licensed building work contractor at the person's own expense | Section 37(7) |
| A certificate from a qualified person that the remedial work has been done properly | Section 37(8) |
| On failure to do remedial work: an offence (up to $50,000 for an individual, $250,000 for a company) and compensation to the applicant | Section 37(9) |
The section 37 jurisdiction applies whether the contract or the work began before or after the section commenced (section 37(1)). Where a claim exceeds $100,000, it can be referred to the District Court on application (section 40).
How does building indemnity insurance fit?
Building indemnity insurance under Division 3 of Part 5 is separate from the warranties. It does not apply to work for which development approval was not required, or to minor domestic building work (section 33(2)). Where it applies, a complying policy must be in force, and the owner given a certificate, before the work is performed (section 34). For policies entered into on or after 10 November 2025, the limit of the insurer’s liability for each dwelling must be not less than $250,000 (regulation 20).
The warranties are the owner’s rights against the contractor. The policy responds in the circumstances its terms and Division 3 provide, which is a separate question from whether a warranty was breached.
How should a contract deal with defects?
A contract cannot shorten or limit the warranties, but it can organise how defects are found and fixed. A defects regime that helps both sides covers:
- a handover inspection and a written list of incomplete or defective items, signed at completion, which also fixes the completion date for section 32(5);
- a defects period during which the contractor returns to fix reported items, stated to be in addition to the statutory warranties and not a substitute for them;
- how the owner reports a defect and how quickly the contractor must respond;
- access for the contractor to inspect and fix;
- written advice where the owner chooses a method or material against the contractor’s recommendation, for section 32(7);
- what happens to retention or the final payment while defects are outstanding.
How similar matters tend to play out
These are illustrations built from the rules above, not predictions. Each depends on its own facts.
A leaking shower four years after a bathroom renovation. The owner who commissioned the work sold the house a year ago. The buyer succeeds to the warranty rights (section 32(3)) and is within five years of completion (section 32(5)). The builder’s “12-month warranty” clause is void under section 42. The dispute is whether the waterproofing met accepted trade standards, and the builder’s site records decide much of it.
A cracked slab claimed in year seven. The owners rely on the 10-year limit in the planning legislation. A claim relying on the section 32 warranties is out of time, because the five-year limit applies and the 10-year provision does not displace it (Duncan v Bert Farina Constructions Pty Ltd [2024] SASCA 67 at [3]).
A settlement signed at handover. A builder pays $8,000 to settle a list of defects and takes a release of all claims “known or unknown”. Two years later, a new defect appears. The release is void so far as it covers defects that were unknown when it was signed (Forlyle Pty Ltd v Tiver [2007] SASC 464 at [19]), and the owner can claim.
How we act on warranty and defect claims
We act for builders and trades from the first letter of complaint through to the Magistrates Court, and we draft the defect terms that keep the next dispute smaller.
| Stage | What happens | What we do |
|---|---|---|
| 1. The claim | A defect list, letter or application arrives | We check the dates against section 32(5) and the claimant's standing under section 32(3) or (4) |
| 2. The evidence | Contract, specifications, variations, site records, photos and reports | We identify where the work met the contract and trade standards, and any section 32(7) defence |
| 3. The response | A reasoned response or an offer to rectify | We draft it so it does not concede what is not owed |
| 4. Court | A section 37 application, or a referral under section 40 | We act in the proceedings and on remedial work orders |
| 5. Next contract | The lessons from the dispute | We revise your defect, handover and variation terms |
We cannot promise to defeat a warranty claim. We can make sure it is answered on the law and the evidence rather than on assumptions about time limits and contract terms that do not survive section 42.
Before you reply to a defect claim. Book a same-day free 30-minute consultation or call (08) 7094 2021.
Statutory warranty case law
These are the South Australian decisions this guide relies on. The case notes state what each court decided.
| Case | Court | Principle | Pinpoint |
|---|---|---|---|
| Duncan v Bert Farina Constructions Pty Ltd [2024] SASCA 67 | Court of Appeal | The 10-year planning law limit is a long stop that does not displace the five-year limit in section 32(5); a builder may rely on the shorter period | [1] to [3], [141] |
| Forlyle Pty Ltd v Tiver [2007] SASC 464 | Supreme Court (Full Court) | A development agreement for a house carries the warranties; a release of future defect claims is void under section 42 to that extent and can be severed | [3], [19], [24] |
Case notes
Duncan v Bert Farina Constructions Pty Ltd [2024] SASCA 67
Owners sued the builder of their house for defects, relying on the section 32(2) warranties, and argued that section 73 of the Development Act 1993 (and section 159 of the Planning, Development and Infrastructure Act 2016) gave them 10 years. The Court of Appeal held that those provisions operate only as a 10-year long stop; they do not authorise claims at any time up to 10 years, there is no inconsistency with the five-year limit in section 32(5), and where both apply a respondent may rely on the shorter period ([3]). The appeal was dismissed ([141]), affirming the District Court’s answer to the preliminary question ([2]).
Forlyle Pty Ltd v Tiver [2007] SASC 464
The Full Court agreed that a development agreement for a house was a domestic building work contract carrying the section 32 warranties ([3]). It held that a compromise by which owners agreed not to claim for future defects excluded, limited, modified or waived those warranties and was void under section 42 to that extent ([19]). The words “or unknown” were severed and the appeal and cross-appeal on that point were dismissed ([24]).
Frequently asked questions
How long is a builder's warranty in South Australia?
Proceedings for breach of the statutory warranties must be commenced within five years after completion of the building work, and that period cannot be extended (section 32(5), (6) of the Building Work Contractors Act 1995). The Court of Appeal held in 2024 that the 10-year planning law limit does not displace it.
What is covered by a builder's warranty in SA?
Six statutory warranties: proper work to accepted trade standards and the agreed plans and specifications, good and proper materials, compliance with statutory requirements, reasonable diligence where no completion period is set, fitness for human habitation for a new house, and fitness for a purpose the owner made known (section 32(2)).
Do statutory warranties apply to renovations and small jobs?
Yes. They are implied in every domestic building work contract, including renovations and minor domestic building work under $20,000.
Does the warranty transfer to a new owner when a house is sold?
Yes. A person who purchases or otherwise acquires a house succeeds to the previous owner’s rights under the statutory warranties (section 32(3)).
Is there a 10-year builder's warranty in South Australia?
Not for claims relying on the statutory warranties. The planning legislation contains a 10-year long stop for claims about defective building work, but the Court of Appeal held in Duncan v Bert Farina Constructions Pty Ltd [2024] SASCA 67 that it does not displace the five-year limit in section 32(5).
Can a builder limit the warranty in the contract?
No. Section 42 makes void any exclusion, limitation, modification or waiver of a warranty implied by the Act. A clause limiting warranty claims to 12 months or to the contract price is void to that extent.
Can a homeowner sign away future defect claims in a settlement?
Not effectively. The Full Court held in Forlyle Pty Ltd v Tiver [2007] SASC 464 that a release of claims for future, unknown defects is void under section 42 to that extent, while a settlement of known defects can stand.
What if the owner chose the materials or method against the builder's advice?
The builder has a defence if it proves the deficiencies arose from instructions the owner insisted on contrary to the builder’s written advice (section 32(7)).
Where do I make a building defect claim in SA?
In the Magistrates Court under section 37, where the dispute involves whether the work was performed in accordance with the contract. The Court can order remedial work, payment or compensation. Claims over $100,000 can be referred to the District Court (section 40).
Do statutory warranties apply to subcontractors?
The warranties are implied in the domestic building work contract between the builder and the owner, and a subcontract is not a domestic building work contract (section 3). A subcontractor answers to the builder under the subcontract, and subcontract disputes can be joined to the owner’s proceedings under section 37(4).
Do I need a lawyer for a building defect claim?
The law does not require one. A defect claim turns on dates, documents and the exact terms of the contract, and we check those first so the response does not concede what is not owed.