Throwing Missiles SA: Section 51 Charges, Intent and Penalties
Throwing missile charges in South Australia
Throwing a missile is an offence under section 51 of the Summary Offences Act 1953 (SA). Throwing something intending to injure, annoy or frighten a person, or to damage property, carries up to 2 years imprisonment; doing it recklessly carries up to 1 year. A thrown bottle, can or rock can all found the charge. Talon Legal defends throwing missile charges in Magistrates Courts across South Australia. Book a same-day free 30-minute consultation or call (08) 7094 2021.
Throwing missiles key facts
| Issue | Position in South Australia |
|---|---|
| Governing law | Section 51 of the Summary Offences Act 1953 (SA), in force in its current form since 15 October 2012. Current to 19 November 2026. |
| Intention offence | Throwing a missile, without lawful excuse, intending to injure, annoy or frighten any person or to damage any property: up to 2 years imprisonment (section 51(1)). |
| Recklessness offence | Throwing a missile, without lawful excuse, reckless as to whether it injures, annoys or frightens a person or damages property, or may do so: up to 1 year imprisonment (section 51(2)). |
| Harm need not be proved | No one need actually be injured, annoyed or frightened, and no property need actually be damaged (section 51(3)). |
| "Throw" | Includes discharging or projecting by any mechanism or device (section 51(4)). |
| Lawful excuse | The defendant must prove any lawful excuse relied on (section 5). |
| Court | Both are summary offences, heard in the Magistrates Court (section 5(2)(b) of the Criminal Procedure Act 1921 (SA)). |
| Expiation | Section 51 fixes no expiation fee. |
| Time limit | Proceedings must start within 2 years of the alleged offence (section 52(1)(b) of the Criminal Procedure Act). |
| Related charges | Throwing a prescribed object at a vehicle on a road (section 32A of the Criminal Law Consolidation Act 1935 (SA), up to 5 years); assault; violent disorder. |
| Without a conviction | Possible where the court imposes a fine or community service and section 24 of the Sentencing Act 2017 (SA) applies. |
| First step | Same-day free 30-minute consultation. Call (08) 7094 2021. |
Charged with throwing a missile? What section 51 covers
Section 51 of the Summary Offences Act 1953 (SA) creates two offences of throwing a missile without lawful excuse: one where the person intends harm, annoyance, fright or damage, and one where the person is reckless about it. This guide sets out throwing missiles SA law: what the prosecution must prove, the penalties, lawful excuse, the 2012 rewrite of the section, and the more serious charges for throwing at vehicles. It states the law current to 19 November 2026.
Throwing missiles is one of the summary offences SA charges that can be laid with others. A missile thrown during a group brawl can be part of violent disorder, and a missile that hits someone may be charged as assault. Throwing at a person in a way that frightens others nearby can also be affray.
Free Consultation. The difference between intention and recklessness halves the maximum penalty. Book a same-day free 30-minute consultation or call (08) 7094 2021.
On this page
- What are the two throwing offences?
- What must the prosecution prove?
- What is a lawful excuse?
- How did section 51 change in 2012?
- What is the penalty for throwing a missile?
- Throwing at police, people or vehicles
- How similar cases tend to play out
- How we defend throwing missile charges
- Throwing missiles case law
- Frequently asked questions
What are the two throwing offences?
Section 51 separates the two offences by the state of mind of the person throwing.
| Intention offence | Recklessness offence | |
|---|---|---|
| Section | 51(1) | 51(2) |
| State of mind | Intending to injure, annoy or frighten any person, or to damage any property | Reckless as to whether the throw injures, annoys or frightens any person, or damages any property, or may do so |
| Without lawful excuse | Yes | Yes |
| Maximum penalty | Imprisonment for 2 years | Imprisonment for 1 year |
| Court | Magistrates Court | Magistrates Court |
A person is reckless if he or she is aware of a substantial risk that the act could injure, annoy or frighten any person or damage any property, and does the act despite the risk and without adequate justification (section 51(4)). That is a subjective test: the question is what the person was aware of, not what a careful person would have realised.
What must the prosecution prove?
The prosecution must prove each element beyond reasonable doubt, except lawful excuse, which is for the defence (section 5).
A throw
“Throw” includes to discharge or project by means of any mechanism or device (section 51(4)), so a slingshot or a launcher is covered as well as a hand throw.
A missile
The Act does not define “missile”, so the word has its ordinary meaning. The objects in the cases include a bottle (Webb v Police [2007] SASC 4) and a syringe (Coyle v Police [2001] SASC 43). The violent disorder provision gives the example of a missile of a kind capable of causing injury thrown at or towards a person (section 6A).
Intention or recklessness
For section 51(1), the prosecution must prove the person intended to injure, annoy or frighten a person, or to damage property. For section 51(2), it must prove recklessness in the sense defined in section 51(4). Evidence about where the person was, what they could see and what was nearby bears on what they intended or were aware of.
No harm needs to be proved
It is not necessary to prove that anyone was in fact injured, annoyed or frightened, or that property was in fact damaged (section 51(3)). A bottle that lands harmlessly can still found the charge.
What is a lawful excuse?
Both offences require the throw to be without lawful excuse. Under section 5 of the Summary Offences Act, where an offence is committed by doing an act without lawful excuse, the prosecution need not prove the absence of a lawful excuse; the onus is on the defendant to prove any excuse relied on.
“Lawful excuse” is narrower than “reasonable excuse”. In Yuen v Police [2012] SASC 149, about possessing prohibited weapons without lawful excuse under section 15(1b) of the same Act, White J held that the expression referred to some positive legal authority, express or implied, and that an innocent or understandable reason may amount to a reasonable excuse without making the conduct lawful ([61] to [63]). Yuen concerned a different offence; whether the same reading applies to section 51 is a question for the court. Separately, self-defence under section 15 of the Criminal Law Consolidation Act 1935 (SA) is a defence to a charge of any offence, so it can apply to a throwing charge.
How did section 51 change in 2012?
Section 51 was substituted with effect from 15 October 2012. The former section made it an offence to discharge a firearm or throw a stone or other missile without reasonable cause and so as to injure, annoy or frighten, or be likely to injure, annoy or frighten, any person, or so as to damage, or be likely to damage, any property, with a maximum of $10,000 or 2 years imprisonment.
| Former section 51 (to 14 October 2012) | Current section 51 | |
|---|---|---|
| Conduct | Discharging a firearm, or throwing a stone or other missile | Throwing a missile, including discharging or projecting by a mechanism or device |
| Excuse | Without reasonable cause | Without lawful excuse |
| Fault | "So as to" injure or be likely to injure, annoy, frighten or damage | Intention (subsection (1)) or recklessness (subsection (2)) |
| Penalty | $10,000 or 2 years | 2 years (intention); 1 year (recklessness) |
The change matters for the older cases. Decisions on the former section said that the prosecution did not have to prove an intention to frighten or injure, only a deliberate act of throwing or discharging (John v Police [2002] SASC 112 at [5]; Webb v Police [2007] SASC 4 at [12]). The current section expressly requires intention or recklessness, so those decisions do not state the fault element for a charge laid today. Their facts and sentencing remarks are still useful as illustrations.
What is the penalty for throwing a missile?
The maximum penalty is imprisonment for 2 years for the intention offence (section 51(1)) and imprisonment for 1 year for the recklessness offence (section 51(2)). Both are summary offences (section 5(2)(b) of the Criminal Procedure Act 1921 (SA)), dealt with in the Magistrates Court. Section 51 fixes no expiation fee, and a prosecution must be started within 2 years of the alleged offence (section 52(1)(b)).
The court is not limited to imprisonment. It can impose a fine or community service, and where it does, it may decline to record a conviction if the defendant is unlikely to reoffend and good reason exists, having regard to character, antecedents, age or condition, the trifling nature of the offence, or other extenuating circumstances (section 24 of the Sentencing Act 2017 (SA)).
Two sentencing appeals decided under the former section show what courts treat as serious:
- In Webb v Police [2007] SASC 4, a young man with no prior convictions threw a bottle over a fence in the direction of police vehicles after police came to a party that had got out of hand. Layton J agreed that the presence of police was aggravating, noted the community interest in protecting police from gratuitous danger, and dismissed an appeal against 21 days imprisonment, suspended on a 2 year bond ([12] to [21]).
- In Coyle v Police [2001] SASC 43, a man threw a syringe in a way likely to frighten, injure or annoy a person against whom he had a long-running vendetta. Olsson J described the offence as far from trivial given fears about needlestick injuries, and upheld the recording of a conviction with a good behaviour bond ([3], [33], [41] to [42]).
Throwing at police, people or vehicles
What was thrown, and at whom, can lead to a more serious charge than section 51.
- Vehicles on a road. Throwing a prescribed object at, or dropping one on, a vehicle being driven on a road or road-related area, or run on a busway, railway or tramway, is an offence carrying up to 5 years imprisonment (section 32A of the Criminal Law Consolidation Act 1935 (SA)). The objects covered are those prescribed by regulation, and the vehicle can be moving or stationary.
- People. An assault includes doing an act of which the intended purpose is to apply force to another person (section 20(1)(d) of the Criminal Law Consolidation Act), so a throw aimed at someone can be charged as assault whether or not it hits. Assault carries up to 2 years for a basic offence (section 20(3)).
- Police. Throwing towards police was treated as aggravating on sentence in Webb ([13] to [14]).
- Groups. Where 3 or more people use or threaten unlawful violence, a thrown missile can be part of violent disorder, which carries up to $10,000 or 2 years (section 6A).
How similar cases tend to play out
Three illustrations of how section 51 applies to ordinary facts. They are not predictions. Every case turns on its evidence, the person’s record and the court.
Lower range. At a festival, a 19 year old throws a plastic water bottle towards a stage, and it lands short. Security hand him to police. The prosecution must prove he intended to annoy or frighten someone, or was aware of a substantial risk that it would (section 51(1), (2), (4)). With no record and a job to protect, the realistic aim may be the recklessness count, or a penalty without conviction under section 24.
Middle range. Outside a hotel at closing time, a man throws a glass bottle at a group he has argued with. It smashes near them. Intention to frighten is open on those facts (section 51(1)), and if the bottle was aimed at a person, assault may be charged as well (section 20(1)(d)).
Upper range. From an overpass, someone throws a rock onto a car being driven below. That falls within section 32A of the Criminal Law Consolidation Act if the object is of a prescribed class, with a maximum of 5 years, and more serious charges are possible if anyone is hurt.
How we defend throwing missile charges
Throwing charges can turn on two questions: what the person was thinking when they threw, and whether the evidence proves it. We test the footage and witness accounts against the difference between intention and recklessness, because that difference halves the maximum penalty.
| Stage | What happens | What we do |
|---|---|---|
| Arrest or report | Police arrest or report the person, sometimes with assault or violent disorder charges. | Advise on the interview, where what the person says about their intention matters most. |
| Disclosure | The prosecution provides statements, footage and any photographs of the object. | Check what was thrown, from where, towards what, and what the person could see. |
| Charge review | The charge may be under section 51(1) or (2), or another provision. | Test whether intention can be proved, and whether a lesser count fits. |
| Negotiation | Charges can be withdrawn or reduced. | Seek the recklessness count, or withdrawal, in writing. |
| Hearing or sentence | A contested hearing in the Magistrates Court, or a sentence on a plea. | Run the defence, or seek a penalty without conviction where section 24 applies. |
We cannot promise a particular result, and no lawyer can. We can make sure the prosecution proves the state of mind it alleges, not just the throw.
Every hour matters. Book a same-day free 30-minute consultation, or call (08) 7094 2021 now.
Throwing missiles case law
These are the South Australian decisions this guide relies on. John, Webb and Coyle were decided under the former section 51, and Yuen concerned a weapons offence in the same Act. The case notes state what each court decided.
| Case | Court | Principle | Pinpoint |
|---|---|---|---|
| John v Police [2002] SASC 112 | Supreme Court | Former section: no specific intent needed; the prosecution must still prove each element | [1], [5], [20] to [22] |
| Webb v Police [2007] SASC 4 | Supreme Court | Former section: bottle thrown towards police at a party; presence of police aggravating | [1], [12] to [14], [21] |
| Coyle v Police [2001] SASC 43 | Supreme Court | Former section: syringe thrown at a person; conviction properly recorded | [1], [3], [33], [41] to [42] |
| Yuen v Police [2012] SASC 149 | Supreme Court | "Without lawful excuse" requires positive legal authority; the defendant bears the onus | [55], [61] to [63] |
Case notes
John v Police [2002] SASC 112
The appellant was convicted under the former section 51(1) of discharging a firearm so as to frighten a person. Lander J said the Magistrate erred in requiring proof of a specific intention to frighten ([5]), and held that the prosecution had not proved the second element, because there was no evidence the victim was frightened by the discharge rather than by her horse ([18] to [20]). The appeal was allowed and a verdict of not guilty entered ([22]).
Webb v Police [2007] SASC 4
The appellant pleaded guilty under the former section 51(1) to throwing a bottle so as to be likely to injure a person or damage property, after police attended a party that had got out of hand ([1], [4] to [6]). Layton J said the offence then required a deliberate throw, not an intention to injure ([12]), treated the presence of police as aggravating ([13] to [14]), and dismissed the appeal against a suspended sentence of 21 days ([20] to [21]).
Coyle v Police [2001] SASC 43
The appellant pleaded guilty under the former section 51(1) to throwing a syringe so as to be likely to frighten, injure or annoy a person, and was convicted and placed on a bond ([1], [3]). Olsson J held the offence was far from trivial ([33]) and that recording a conviction was the only likely means of bringing home that such conduct would not be tolerated, and dismissed the appeal ([41] to [42]).
Yuen v Police [2012] SASC 149
Under section 5 of the Summary Offences Act, the appellant bore the onus of proving the lawful excuse he relied on for possessing prohibited weapons ([55]). White J held that “without lawful excuse” in section 15(1b) refers to some positive legal authority, and that a collector’s innocent interest might be a reasonable excuse but did not make possession lawful ([61] to [63]).
Frequently asked questions
Is throwing things at people illegal in SA?
Yes. Throwing a missile without lawful excuse intending to injure, annoy or frighten a person, or to damage property, is an offence under section 51(1) of the Summary Offences Act 1953 (SA). Doing it recklessly is an offence under section 51(2).
What is the penalty for throwing a missile in SA?
Up to 2 years imprisonment if the person intended to injure, annoy or frighten someone or damage property, and up to 1 year if the person was reckless. The court can impose a lesser penalty, and in a suitable case a fine without a conviction.
Does the missile have to hit someone?
No. It is not necessary to prove that anyone was injured, annoyed or frightened, or that property was damaged (section 51(3)). A throw that misses can found the charge.
What counts as a missile?
The Act does not define the word, so it has its ordinary meaning. Bottles and syringes are examples from the cases, and “throw” includes discharging or projecting by a mechanism or device (section 51(4)).
What is the difference between the intention and recklessness offences?
The intention offence requires proof that the person meant to injure, annoy or frighten someone or damage property, and carries up to 2 years. The recklessness offence requires proof the person was aware of a substantial risk of that and threw anyway without adequate justification, and carries up to 1 year.
What is a lawful excuse for throwing something?
In Yuen v Police [2012] SASC 149, about a weapons offence, lawful excuse meant some positive legal authority for the conduct, not just a reason that seems understandable. The defendant must prove any lawful excuse (section 5 of the Summary Offences Act). Self-defence is a separate defence to any offence.
Is throwing a rock at a car a more serious offence?
It can be. Throwing a prescribed object at a vehicle being driven on a road is an offence under section 32A of the Criminal Law Consolidation Act 1935 (SA), with a maximum of 5 years imprisonment.
Can throwing a bottle be charged as assault?
Yes. An assault includes an act intended to apply force to another person (section 20(1)(d) of the Criminal Law Consolidation Act), so a bottle thrown at someone can be charged as assault whether or not it hits.
Can I avoid a conviction for throwing a missile?
Possibly. If the court imposes a fine or community service, section 24 of the Sentencing Act 2017 (SA) allows it to do so without recording a conviction where the person is unlikely to reoffend and good reason exists.
Do I need a lawyer for a throwing missile charge?
The law does not require one. But the choice between the intention and recklessness offences, and whether a conviction is recorded, can halve the maximum penalty or keep a record clean, and we deal with those questions on the evidence.
South Australian courts we attend for throwing missile charges
We defend throwing missile and public order charges in the Adelaide Magistrates Court and the suburban and regional Magistrates Courts listed below.
Courts we attend
Book a same-day free 30-minute consultation or call (08) 7094 2021.