Violent Disorder SA: Section 6A Charges, Penalties and Defences

Violent disorder charges in South Australia

Violent disorder is the charge under section 6A of the Summary Offences Act 1953 (SA) for three or more people who use or threaten unlawful violence together. It carries up to $10,000 or 2 years imprisonment, and it can be charged with affray or assault after a fight in or outside a venue. Talon Legal defends violent disorder charges in Magistrates Courts across South Australia. Book a same-day free 30-minute consultation or call (08) 7094 2021.


Violent disorder key facts

IssuePosition in South Australia
Governing lawSection 6A of the Summary Offences Act 1953 (SA). Current to 19 November 2026.
The offenceThree or more people present together use or threaten unlawful violence, and their conduct, taken together, would cause a person of reasonable firmness present at the scene to fear for their personal safety (section 6A(1)).
Who is guiltyEach person who uses or threatens unlawful violence, but only if that person intends to use or threaten violence or is aware that their conduct may be violent or threaten violence (section 6A(1), (5)).
Maximum penaltyA fine of $10,000 or 2 years imprisonment (section 6A(1)).
CourtA summary offence, heard in the Magistrates Court (section 5(2)(b) of the Criminal Procedure Act 1921 (SA)).
WherePublic places and private places (section 6A(4)).
A frightened witnessNot needed. No person of reasonable firmness need actually be, or be likely to be, present (section 6A(3)).
ExpiationNone. Section 6A fixes no expiation fee.
Time limitProceedings must start within 2 years of the alleged offence (section 52(1)(b) of the Criminal Procedure Act).
Defences that runSelf-defence, because the violence must be unlawful; identification; whether 3 people used or threatened violence; whether a person of reasonable firmness would have feared for their safety.
Related chargesAffray (section 83C of the Criminal Law Consolidation Act 1935 (SA), up to 3 or 5 years) and riot (section 83B, 12 or more people, up to 7 or 10 years).
Without a convictionPossible where the court imposes a fine or community service and section 24 of the Sentencing Act 2017 (SA) applies.
First stepSame-day free 30-minute consultation. Call (08) 7094 2021.

Charged with violent disorder? What section 6A covers

Section 6A of the Summary Offences Act 1953 (SA) makes violent disorder an offence. It commenced on 8 June 2008, together with the riot and affray offences in sections 83B and 83C of the Criminal Law Consolidation Act 1935 (SA). This guide sets out violent disorder SA law: what the prosecution must prove, the penalty, self-defence, how the charge differs from affray and riot, and how courts treat group violence. It states the law current to 19 November 2026.

Violent disorder is one of the public order charges in the summary offences SA group. A fight involving only one or two people may instead be charged as affray, assault or fighting in a public place. Abuse or rowdiness without violence may be charged as disorderly or offensive behaviour.

Free Consultation. Get advice before any police interview about the incident. Book a same-day free 30-minute consultation or call (08) 7094 2021.

ExcellentGoogle star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 55.097 reviews
5.0Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5
Excellent97 reviews
Posted on Google Google
Muhammad Zubair profile picture
Muhammad Zubair
29 October 2026
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
Talon Legal is the best law firm in the Adelaide. Dan was able to resolve my case before time, achieving a favourable outcome. I would highly recommend Talon Legal to anyone seeking professional legal assistance. Talon Legal develops effective legal strategies to achieve the best possible outcomes.
Posted on Google Google
Jessie W profile picture
Jessie W
26 October 2026
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
I had a great experience dealing with Danial at Talon Legal. From our initial conversation, he was professional, approachable and genuinely interested in understanding our business and its needs. He took the time to listen, explain things clearly and offer thoughtful, practical advice. I particularly appreciated his patience, honesty and the time he dedicated to our discussions. Although we haven’t engaged the firm for further work at this stage, the experience has left a very positive impression. I would certainly feel confident reaching out to Danial again for any future legal matters. Thank you, Danial, for your time and professionalism. It’s been a pleasure dealing with you!
Posted on Google Google
Angela Carter profile picture
Angela Carter
12 October 2026
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
Was a scary experience, uut thenks to your expertise, i got the best possible outcome.
Posted on Google Google
S Google profile picture
S Google
24 September 2026
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
Dan went above and beyond our expectations to deliver professional, highly detailed and very well thought out information. He included extra documents just to help us out and this was much appreciated.
Posted on Google Google
Calvin Munatswa profile picture
Calvin Munatswa
24 August 2026
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
I’m extremely happy with the service I received from Dan. He was professional, responsive, knowledgeable and genuinely committed to achieving the best possible outcome. I really appreciate the hard work, guidance and support throughout the process. Thank you for doing such a great job. I would highly recommend your services to anyone looking for a reliable and dedicated lawyer.
Posted on Google Google
Marcelle Ayoubi profile picture
Marcelle Ayoubi
4 August 2026
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
Highly recommend Dan! He was prompt, reliable and efficient, with excellent communication throughout the entire process. His knowledge and professionalism gave me confidence, and he achieved a good outcome. Dan took a lot of the stress out of what could have been an overwhelming experience. Thank you, Dan, for all your support and assistance!
Posted on Google Google
Neb Trivic profile picture
Neb Trivic
24 July 2026
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
Very knowledgable, helpfull and got the best outcome hoped for.
Posted on Google Google
Anton Simdyankin profile picture
Anton Simdyankin
21 July 2026
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
Timely quote, responses and overall great experience. 100% Recommend
Posted on Google Google
Tania Stubberfield profile picture
Tania Stubberfield
16 July 2026
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
I highly recommend Talon Legal and especially Daniel Esmaili. During our initial conversation for a driving offence, Dan was incredibly honest and told me that I didn't really need legal representation. He was completely down-to-earth and non-judgmental, reassuring me that people make poor choices sometimes. I felt more at ease and I chose to hire him anyway to avoid the anxiety of a court appearance, and it was the best decision I could have made. He took care of everything from start to finish, appearing in court on my behalf so I didn't have to attend at all. He explained everything clearly without using confusing legal jargon. He was also incredibly thoughtful and personal, asking how my birthday trip away went with family. Thanks to Dan, we got a fantastic outcome with a significantly reduced suspension time and a minimal fine. Dan even went above and beyond by telling me to contact him before I start driving again to double-check that my suspension is fully completed and my licence paperwork is processed correctly. On top of the amazing result, the fees were surprisingly affordable without compromising on performance and integrity. If you want an empathetic, honest, affordable and highly capable lawyer, then Dan's your man. Thankyou again Daniel Esmaili at Talon Legal.
Posted on Google Google
Bill P profile picture
Bill P
30 June 2026
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
We recently engaged Dan Esmaili from Talon Legal to assist our family with a motor vehicle road rule expiation and related court matter. From the very beginning, Dan was professional, clear, and extremely supportive. He took the time to explain the process in a way we could understand, kept us informed throughout, and handled the matter with care and confidence. Most importantly, Dan achieved a successful outcome for our family, which we are very grateful for. We sincerely appreciate his guidance, responsiveness, and dedication. We would highly recommend Dan Esmaili and Talon Legal to anyone needing strong legal support and professional representation.
Verified by Trustindex
Trustindex verified badge is the Universal Symbol of Trust. Only the greatest companies can get the verified badge who has a review score above 4.5, based on customer reviews over the past 12 months. Read more

What is violent disorder?

Violent disorder is committed when 3 or more people who are present together use or threaten unlawful violence, and their conduct, taken together, is such as would cause a person of reasonable firmness present at the scene to fear for his or her personal safety (section 6A(1)). Each of the people using or threatening unlawful violence is guilty of the offence.

Four parts of the section widen it:

  • the 3 or more people need not use or threaten violence at the same time (section 6A(2));
  • no person of reasonable firmness need actually be, or be likely to be, at the scene (section 6A(3));
  • it can be committed in private places as well as public ones (section 6A(4));
  • violence includes violent conduct towards property, and is not limited to conduct causing or intended to cause injury or damage (section 6A(7)).

The section gives its own example of violence: throwing at, or towards, a person a missile of a kind capable of causing injury, which misses or falls short.

Section 6A(5) limits who is guilty. A person commits the offence only if he or she intends to use or threaten violence, or is aware that his or her conduct may be violent or threaten violence. Under section 6A(6), that limit does not affect the count of how many people used or threatened violence.


What must the prosecution prove?

The prosecution must prove each element beyond reasonable doubt. The headings below follow the words of section 6A. The Supreme Court has listed the elements of affray, which is built the same way, in Jessen v Police [2011] SASC 209 at [7] and Police v Forbes [2015] SASC 94 at [3].

Three or more people, present together

At least 3 people must be present together and must each use or threaten unlawful violence (section 6A(1)). A person who is at the scene but does not use or threaten violence is not guilty, and on the words of the section is not one of the 3. Because section 6A(6) keeps the fault element out of the count, a person whose own state of mind would not make them guilty can still be counted.

Using or threatening unlawful violence

The violence must be unlawful. That is the opening for self-defence, explained below. The violence need not cause or be meant to cause injury, and violence towards property counts (section 6A(7)).

Section 6A has no equivalent of section 83C(3), which says that for affray a threat cannot be made by words alone.

Conduct that would frighten a person of reasonable firmness

The test is objective. The question is whether the conduct of the group, taken together, would cause a person of reasonable firmness present at the scene to fear for his or her personal safety. Nobody need actually be frightened, and nobody need be there (section 6A(3)).

The element can decide the case. In O’Neil v Police [2018] SASC 137, the Supreme Court recorded that a magistrate had dismissed a violent disorder count arising from a fight because the prosecution had failed to prove that a person of reasonable firmness present would have feared for their personal safety, and had not disproved self-defence ([5]).

The person’s own intent or awareness

The prosecution must prove that the person charged intended to use or threaten violence, or was aware that his or her conduct may be violent or threaten violence (section 6A(5)). An accidental collision in a crowd is not enough.

Public or private place

Unlike the public place offences in section 7 of the Act, violent disorder needs no public place. A fight at a house party is covered (section 6A(4)).


What is the penalty for violent disorder?

The maximum penalty is a fine of $10,000 or imprisonment for 2 years (section 6A(1)).

Because the maximum term is 2 years, violent disorder is a summary offence (section 5(2)(b) of the Criminal Procedure Act 1921 (SA)) and is dealt with in the Magistrates Court. Section 6A fixes no expiation fee, so it cannot be dealt with by an expiation notice, and a prosecution must be started within 2 years of the date of the alleged offence (section 52(1)(b)).

A conviction is not automatic. If the court proposes to impose a fine or community service, it may do so without recording a conviction where it is of the opinion that the defendant is unlikely to commit such an offence again and that good reason exists, having regard to the defendant’s character, antecedents, age or condition, the trifling nature of the offence, or other extenuating circumstances (section 24 of the Sentencing Act 2017 (SA)). Avoiding a conviction matters most for people whose work, licences or travel depend on a clean record.


How is violent disorder different from affray and riot?

The three public order offences were introduced together and share the reasonable firmness test. They differ in how many people are needed and in how serious they are.

Violent disorderAffrayRiot
SectionSection 6A, Summary Offences ActSection 83C, Criminal Law Consolidation ActSection 83B, Criminal Law Consolidation Act
People needed3 or more, present togetherOne is enough12 or more, present together, for a common purpose
Maximum penalty$10,000 or 2 years3 years; 5 years if aggravated7 years; 10 years if aggravated
Threat by words aloneThe section is silentNot enough (section 83C(3))The section is silent
Where it is heardMagistrates Court, as a summary offenceCan be dealt with in the Magistrates Court as a summary offence, with committal to the District Court for sentence if more than 2 years imprisonment is warranted (section 83C(7))A superior court, as a major indictable offence (section 5(3) of the Criminal Procedure Act)

Two practical differences follow. An affray conviction is taken to be a conviction for an indictable offence even where the Magistrates Court dealt with it (section 83C(8)); a violent disorder conviction is a conviction for a summary offence. And on a trial for riot, a jury not satisfied of riot but satisfied of violent disorder may convict of violent disorder instead (section 83B(8)).

Affray can be committed by one person acting alone, and where 2 or more people are involved, it is their conduct taken together that is considered (Jessen v Police [2011] SASC 209 at [6]). Where police can prove only one or two participants, the charge may be affray or assault instead.


Can self-defence apply to violent disorder?

Yes. Section 6A requires the violence to be unlawful, and section 15 of the Criminal Law Consolidation Act provides a defence where the person genuinely believed the conduct was necessary and reasonable for a defensive purpose, and the conduct was reasonably proportionate to the threat as the person genuinely believed it to be (as summarised in Police v Forbes [2015] SASC 94 at [16]). Once the defence is raised, it is for the prosecution to rebut it (Forbes at [16]).

Jessen v Police [2011] SASC 209 at [8] and Forbes at [16] both proceed on the basis that self-defence can be raised against affray, because of section 15 and because section 83C requires the violence to be unlawful. The same reasoning applies to the words of section 6A, and in O’Neil v Police [2018] SASC 137 the violent disorder count was dismissed at trial because self-defence had not been disproved ([5]).

Group fights test the limits of the defence:

  • A person who willingly engages in an unlawful fight cannot claim to have acted in self-defence (R v Bosworth [2007] SASC 150 at [48]). In Forbes, Duggan AJ noted that if two groups engaged willingly in a fight, self-defence would not be available ([18]).
  • Self-defence cannot justify retaliation or revenge once the danger is over (Marks v Police; Roach v Police [2019] SASC 50 at [50]).
  • There is no rule that a person must retreat before defending themselves, but the chance to retreat is relevant to both limbs of the defence (Jessen at [24]).

In Jessen, the appellant and his group had about 20 minutes in which they could have left before the other group approached, and White J found that his response could not be regarded as reasonably proportionate to the threat he perceived ([33] to [34]). In Marks, the Court said the obvious lawful course for the group was to keep walking ([54]).


How do courts treat group violence?

Sentencing turns on the facts: the violence used, any injuries or weapons, whether the group went looking for trouble, and the person’s role and record. The decisions used in this guide sentenced group violence as affray, which carries higher maximum penalties than violent disorder. They show what courts treat as serious rather than a range for section 6A.

In DPP v Sheehy [2012] SASC 152, a group of motorcycle club members attacked members of a rival club in a nightclub, in revenge for an earlier altercation. On a Crown appeal, Kelly J said the fact that they acted as a group went to the heart of the seriousness of the offending ([26]), that alcohol fuelling their aggression was not a mitigating factor but an aggravating feature ([27]), and that the Magistrate had not appreciated the real gravity of the offending ([29]).

Planning, revenge, numbers and injuries push a case up. A short, unplanned scuffle, a minor role, early cooperation and a good record point the other way, and in a suitable case section 24 of the Sentencing Act allows a fine without a conviction.


How similar cases tend to play out

Three illustrations of how section 6A applies to ordinary facts. They are not predictions. Every case turns on its evidence, the person’s role and record, and the court.

Lower range. A group of five argues with another group outside a takeaway. Two people trade shoves and someone throws a can that falls short. CCTV shows the person charged standing at the back of the group and stepping away when the shoving starts. The prosecution must prove that he used or threatened unlawful violence himself (section 6A(1)) and that he intended or was aware of it (section 6A(5)). Presence alone is not the offence.

Middle range. After a dispute in a bar, four friends follow another group outside and punches are thrown. The person charged says he hit out only after being struck. Self-defence is raised and the prosecution must disprove it (Forbes at [16]). The court will ask whether he joined the fight willingly and whether he could have walked away (Bosworth at [48]; Jessen at [24]; Marks at [54]).

Upper range. A group arranges to confront rivals at a venue and attacks them, and several people are injured. Charges of affray or assault causing harm may be laid alongside, or instead of, violent disorder. The planning, the revenge motive and the alcohol are aggravating (Sheehy at [26] to [27]), and imprisonment is within the range the court can impose.


How we defend violent disorder charges

Where there is CCTV or body-worn camera footage, we get it early and test it against each element for the one person charged, not the group: who did what, when, and in response to what.

StageWhat happensWhat we do
Arrest and interviewPolice may arrest at the scene, and may also charge affray or assault.Advise on the interview and on bail conditions, including any condition not to contact co-accused.
DisclosureThe prosecution provides statements, CCTV and body-worn camera footage.Go through the footage against each element, especially who used or threatened violence.
Charge reviewViolent disorder may be laid with, or instead of, affray or assault.Test the count of 3 people, the reasonable firmness element and whether self-defence is excluded.
NegotiationCharges can be withdrawn, reduced or substituted.Put the weaknesses to the prosecution in writing.
Hearing or sentenceA contested hearing in the Magistrates Court, or a sentence on a plea.Run the defence, or seek a penalty without conviction where section 24 applies.

We cannot promise a particular result, and no lawyer can. We can make sure the prosecution proves every element against the person we act for.

Every hour matters. Book a same-day free 30-minute consultation, or call (08) 7094 2021 now.


Violent disorder case law

These are the South Australian decisions this guide relies on. O’Neil concerned a violent disorder charge; the others concern affray or self-defence in a fight, and are used for the principles the offences share. The case notes state what each court decided.

CaseCourtPrinciplePinpoint
O'Neil v Police [2018] SASC 137Supreme CourtA violent disorder count was dismissed at trial: reasonable firmness not proved and self-defence not disproved[5]
Jessen v Police [2011] SASC 209Supreme CourtElements of affray; self-defence available; no duty to retreat, but the chance to retreat is relevant[6] to [8], [24], [33] to [35]
Police v Forbes [2015] SASC 94Supreme CourtSelf-defence applies to affray and the prosecution must rebut it; willing fighters cannot rely on it[3], [16], [18], [20]
R v Bosworth [2007] SASC 150Court of Criminal AppealA person who willingly engages in an unlawful fight cannot claim self-defence[46] to [49]
Marks v Police; Roach v Police [2019] SASC 50Supreme CourtFighting willingly, or by way of retaliation, is not self-defence[50], [54], [147]
DPP v Sheehy [2012] SASC 152Supreme CourtGroup revenge violence: acting as a group goes to the heart of seriousness, and alcohol aggravates[26] to [27], [29]

Case notes

O'Neil v Police [2018] SASC 137

The appellant was charged with violent disorder under section 6A(1) and with assaulting a police officer after a fight. The Supreme Court recorded that the Magistrate had dismissed the violent disorder count because self-defence had not been disproved and the prosecution had not proved that a person of reasonable firmness present would have feared for their personal safety ([5]). The appeal itself concerned the assault conviction and the sentence for it.

Jessen v Police [2011] SASC 209

White J set out the elements of affray under section 83C ([7]) and noted that, unlike the common law offence, affray can be committed by one person acting alone ([6]). Self-defence can be raised against affray ([8]). Section 15 does not require a person to exhaust the chances to retreat, but those chances are relevant to both limbs of the defence ([24]). The appellant’s group had time to leave before the other group approached, his response was not reasonably proportionate, and the appeal was dismissed ([33] to [35]).

Police v Forbes [2015] SASC 94

A Magistrate acquitted a man charged with aggravated affray over a nightclub fight between motorcycle club members. Duggan AJ said that self-defence can apply to affray and that the prosecution must rebut it ([16]), but noted that if the two groups engaged willingly in a fight, self-defence would not be available ([18]). The prosecution appeal was allowed and a retrial ordered ([20]).

R v Bosworth [2007] SASC 150

The Court of Criminal Appeal explained that a trial judge’s comment that an all-in brawl between two groups leaves no room for self-defence referred to a person who willingly engages in an unlawful fight, who cannot claim to have acted in self-defence ([46] to [49]).

Marks v Police; Roach v Police [2019] SASC 50

Nicholson J said that to engage willingly in a fight is not to act in self-defence, and that self-defence cannot justify retaliation or revenge once the danger is over ([50]). On the evidence, the lawful course open to the group was to keep walking, and there was no evidence to raise self-defence for Roach ([54]). Both appeals were dismissed ([147]).

DPP v Sheehy [2012] SASC 152

On a Crown appeal against sentences for aggravated affray, Kelly J said that the fact the offenders acted as a group went to the heart of the seriousness of the offending ([26]), that alcohol fuelling their aggression was an aggravating feature rather than a mitigating one ([27]), and that the Magistrate had not appreciated the real gravity of the offending ([29]).


Frequently asked questions

What is violent disorder in SA?

Violent disorder is an offence under section 6A of the Summary Offences Act 1953 (SA). It is committed when 3 or more people present together use or threaten unlawful violence, and their conduct, taken together, would cause a person of reasonable firmness present at the scene to fear for their personal safety.

What is the penalty for violent disorder?

The maximum penalty is a fine of $10,000 or 2 years imprisonment (section 6A(1)). The court can impose a lesser penalty, and in a suitable case a fine or community service without recording a conviction under section 24 of the Sentencing Act 2017 (SA).

Is violent disorder a summary offence?

Yes. With a maximum of 2 years imprisonment it is a summary offence under section 5(2)(b) of the Criminal Procedure Act 1921 (SA), and it is dealt with in the Magistrates Court.

What is the difference between violent disorder and affray?

Violent disorder needs at least 3 people using or threatening unlawful violence and carries up to 2 years. Affray, under section 83C of the Criminal Law Consolidation Act 1935 (SA), can be committed by one person and carries up to 3 years, or 5 years if aggravated. For affray, a threat cannot be made by words alone (section 83C(3)).

Can someone be guilty of violent disorder just for being there?

No. Only a person who uses or threatens unlawful violence is guilty (section 6A(1)), and only if that person intends to use or threaten violence or is aware that their conduct may be violent or threaten violence (section 6A(5)).

Can self-defence be raised to a violent disorder charge?

Yes. The violence must be unlawful, and the defence in section 15 of the Criminal Law Consolidation Act can be raised. The prosecution must then disprove it. It does not cover a person who joined a fight willingly or who retaliated after the danger had passed.

Do police need a witness who was frightened?

No. The test is whether a hypothetical person of reasonable firmness present at the scene would have feared for their personal safety. No such person need actually be, or be likely to be, present (section 6A(3)).

Can violent disorder happen on private property?

Yes. Section 6A(4) says the offence may be committed in private as well as in public places, so a fight at a house party or in a private car park is covered.

Can a violent disorder charge be expiated?

No. Section 6A fixes no expiation fee, so the matter goes to court unless the charge is withdrawn.

How long do police have to charge violent disorder?

Two years from the date of the alleged offence. Because it is a summary offence that is not expiable, section 52(1)(b) of the Criminal Procedure Act 1921 (SA) requires proceedings to be commenced within that time.

Do I need a lawyer for a violent disorder charge?

The law does not require one, but group charges are easy to lose without one. We check the footage against each element, test whether 3 people used or threatened violence, and run self-defence where the evidence supports it.


South Australian courts we attend for violent disorder charges

We defend violent disorder charges in the Adelaide Magistrates Court and the suburban and regional Magistrates Courts listed below.

Book a same-day free 30-minute consultation or call (08) 7094 2021.


Talon Legal Insights

Access hundreds of legal precedents and templates.

When you partner with us, you also gain access to a vast repository of regularly updated and ever-expanding legal resources.