Unlawfully on Premises SA: Trespass Offences Under the Summary Offences Act
Unlawfully on premises charges in South Australia
Being on premises for an unlawful purpose or without lawful excuse is an offence under section 17 of the Summary Offences Act 1953 (SA), and refusing to leave after trespassing is an offence under section 17A. Penalties run from $1,250 to 2 years imprisonment depending on the charge and the purpose alleged. Being somewhere without permission is not, by itself, a crime under section 17. Talon Legal defends trespass charges in Magistrates Courts across South Australia. Book a same-day free 30-minute consultation or call (08) 7094 2021.
Unlawfully on premises key facts
| Issue | Position in South Australia |
|---|---|
| Governing law | Sections 17, 17A and 17AB of the Summary Offences Act 1953 (SA). Current to 19 November 2026. |
| Unlawful purpose or no lawful excuse | Being on premises for an unlawful purpose or without lawful excuse: up to 2 years if the purpose is an offence punishable by 2 years or more, otherwise $2,500 or 6 months (section 17(1)). |
| Lawful excuse | The prosecution must prove its absence (section 17(1a)), and the trespass must go beyond a mere civil wrong (Police v Rudloff [2018] SASC 101 at [18]). |
| Failing to leave | A trespass that interferes with the occupier's enjoyment, then failing to leave when asked or returning within 24 hours: $2,500 or 6 months (section 17A(1)). |
| Other trespass offences | Offensive language or behaviour while trespassing, $1,250 (section 17A(2)); refusing name and address, $1,250 (section 17A(2a)); failing to obey a police order to leave, $2,500 or 6 months (section 17(3)). |
| Farms | Higher penalties for primary production premises, including aggravated circumstances (section 17(a1), (a2); section 17A(1)(a)). |
| Premises | Any land, building or structure, or any aircraft, vehicle, ship or boat (sections 17(4), 17A(3)). |
| Court | Summary offences, heard in the Magistrates Court (section 5(2) of the Criminal Procedure Act 1921 (SA)). |
| Time limit | Proceedings must start within 2 years of the alleged offence (section 52(1)(b) of the Criminal Procedure Act). |
| More serious charge | Serious criminal trespass: entering or remaining in a place not open to the public as a trespasser intending to commit certain offences (section 168 of the Criminal Law Consolidation Act 1935 (SA)). |
| Without a conviction | Possible where the court imposes a fine or community service and section 24 of the Sentencing Act 2017 (SA) applies. |
| First step | Same-day free 30-minute consultation. Call (08) 7094 2021. |
Charged with being unlawfully on premises? What sections 17 and 17A cover
The Summary Offences Act 1953 (SA) has several trespass offences. Section 17 punishes being on premises for an unlawful purpose or without lawful excuse. Section 17A punishes trespassers who refuse to leave or come back. Section 17AB deals with gatecrashers at private parties. This guide sets out unlawfully on premises SA law: which offence fits which facts, what the prosecution must prove, the penalties and the defences. It states the law current to 19 November 2026.
These charges sit in the summary offences SA group. Where police allege the person entered a home or building intending to steal or commit another serious offence, the charge may be serious criminal trespass, which carries far higher penalties. Property found on the person may also lead to unlawful possession or theft and receiving charges.
Free Consultation. Being on someone’s land without permission is not automatically a crime. Book a same-day free 30-minute consultation or call (08) 7094 2021.
On this page
- Which trespass offence applies?
- What is "without lawful excuse"?
- What is "for an unlawful purpose"?
- When is refusing to leave an offence?
- What about farms and private parties?
- How is this different from serious criminal trespass?
- What is the penalty for being unlawfully on premises?
- How similar cases tend to play out
- How we defend trespass charges
- Unlawfully on premises case law
- Frequently asked questions
Which trespass offence applies?
The offence charged decides what the prosecution must prove and the maximum penalty.
| Offence | Section | What must be proved | Maximum penalty |
|---|---|---|---|
| On premises for an unlawful purpose | 17(1) | Entered or present on premises for a purpose the prosecution identifies as unlawful | 2 years if the purpose is an offence punishable by 2 years or more; otherwise $2,500 or 6 months |
| On premises without lawful excuse | 17(1) | Entered or present on premises without lawful excuse, in a way that calls for the criminal law | As above |
| Failing to obey a police order to leave | 17(3) | An officer believed on reasonable grounds the person was there to commit an offence and ordered them to leave | $2,500 or 6 months |
| Trespasser failing to leave | 17A(1) | A trespass interfering with the occupier's enjoyment, a request to leave by an authorised person, and failing to leave forthwith or returning within 24 hours | $2,500 or 6 months; $5,000 or 6 months for primary production premises |
| Offensive while trespassing | 17A(2) | Offensive language or behaviour while trespassing | $1,250 |
| Refusing name and address | 17A(2a) | A trespasser asked by an authorised person for name and address | $1,250 |
| Trespassing at a private party | 17AB(4) | Failing to leave a private party immediately when asked, or returning | $5,000 or 1 year |
“Premises” is defined widely: any land, any building or structure, and any aircraft, vehicle, ship or boat (sections 17(4) and 17A(3)).
What is “without lawful excuse”?
For section 17, the prosecution must prove the absence of lawful excuse; the usual rule in section 5, which puts the onus of a lawful excuse on the defendant, does not apply (section 17(1a)).
Lack of permission is not enough. In Police v Rudloff [2018] SASC 101, Peek J said it has long been the law in South Australia that mere presence which would constitute a civil trespass is insufficient for a conviction; the prosecution must prove that the trespass so transcended the mere infringement of a civil right that it calls for the protection of the criminal law and the punishment of the offender ([18]). The Magistrate had convicted a man who entered his neighbour’s riverfront block knowing he had no permission, without considering that element. Peek J held the conduct proved did not reach that threshold, allowed the appeal and dismissed the complaint ([22], [24] to [25]).
The test leaves room for judgment on the facts. In Lee & Rulfs v Police [2009] SASC 263, two men practising parkour climbed onto shop roofs on The Parade at Norwood at about 10.30 pm, alarming members of the public. The Magistrate found the charge proved but recorded no conviction and fined each $200. Nyland J said she might not have reached the same conclusion herself, but was not persuaded the Magistrate erred, and dismissed the appeal ([2] to [4], [16] to [17]).
Peek J also observed that the trespass offences in sections 17A to 17D are much closer to a civil trespass, with lower maximum penalties, and will often be a more appropriate charge than “without lawful excuse” under section 17 (Rudloff at [20]).
What is “for an unlawful purpose”?
Being on premises for an unlawful purpose is a different charge from being there without lawful excuse. The prosecution must identify the purpose it alleges (Pavy v Police [2002] SASC 293 at [37]). If the purpose is the commission of an offence punishable by 2 years imprisonment or more, the maximum rises to 2 years (section 17(1)).
In Pavy, the defendant pleaded guilty to being on premises at Christies Beach for an unlawful purpose and to damaging property, on facts showing he intended to break in to steal. He was sentenced to 10 months imprisonment, which also triggered the balance of a parole sentence. Perry J described it as a serious example of the offence and dismissed the appeal ([1] to [3], [46] to [48]).
Police can also act before anything happens. Where an officer believes on reasonable grounds that a person has entered or is present on premises for the purpose of committing an offence, the officer may order the person to leave, and failing to comply is an offence carrying $2,500 or 6 months (section 17(2), (3)).
When is refusing to leave an offence?
Under section 17A(1), a trespasser commits an offence if:
- the person trespasses on premises;
- the nature of the trespass is such as to interfere with the enjoyment of the premises by the occupier;
- an authorised person (the occupier, someone acting for the occupier, or for schools and Crown premises the person who manages them) asks the person to leave; and
- the person fails to leave forthwith, or trespasses again within 24 hours of being asked to leave.
The initial trespass is not the offence. Section 17A punishes the failure to leave, or the return within 24 hours, after a trespass of that kind (Police v Slobodian [2008] SASC 69 at [22]). The prosecution must prove the person knew, or was reckless as to whether, they were a trespasser ([38]).
Interference with enjoyment is more than physical presence. In King v Police [2007] SASC 93, a man set up a stall on university grounds and refused to remove it or leave when asked. Doyle CJ held that he interfered with the university’s right to manage the use of its premises, that this was not a bare or technical trespass, and that section 17A is not limited to squatters in houses, and he dismissed the appeal against conviction ([16] to [19], [26] to [27]).
A belief that you are entitled to come back does not help once permission has been clearly withdrawn. In Slobodian, a man removed from a Centrelink office by police, and told not to return for 24 hours, came back to collect papers. Gray J held that no claim of right could arise from that belief and that a conviction should be recorded ([3], [49]).
What about farms and private parties?
Since 9 July 2020, trespass on primary production premises carries higher penalties. Entering or being on farm premises for an unlawful purpose or without lawful excuse carries up to 2 years if the purpose is an offence punishable by 2 years or more, otherwise $10,000 or 12 months in aggravated circumstances and $5,000 or 6 months in other cases (section 17(a1)). Aggravated circumstances include interfering with primary production activities, being accompanied by 2 or more people, creating a serious safety risk, risking disease, pests or contamination, and intentionally or recklessly damaging an operation connected with the farm (section 17(a2)). A person found guilty in aggravated circumstances is liable to pay compensation for injury, loss or damage unless exceptional circumstances exist (section 17(3a)).
At a private party, an authorised person who reasonably suspects someone is not entitled to be there can ask for evidence of entitlement, and a gatecrasher who fails to leave immediately when asked, or returns, commits an offence carrying $5,000 or 1 year (section 17AB(1), (4)).
How is this different from serious criminal trespass?
Serious criminal trespass is a much more serious offence under the Criminal Law Consolidation Act 1935 (SA). A person commits it by entering or remaining in a place that is not open to the public, as a trespasser, with the intention of committing an offence to which the section applies: theft or an offence of which theft is an element, an offence against the person, or a property damage offence punishable by imprisonment for 3 years or more (section 168). In a non-residential building the maximum is 10 years for a basic offence and 20 years if aggravated (section 169); in a place of residence the maximum for a basic offence is 15 years (section 170).
The section 17 unlawful purpose charge can cover similar facts at a far lower maximum. In Pavy, Perry J noted the benefit to the defendant of the lesser charges being substituted for the more serious charge originally laid: exposure to a much lower maximum penalty ([38]). Negotiating a serious criminal trespass charge down to a section 17 charge can make a large difference to the maximum penalty.
What is the penalty for being unlawfully on premises?
The maximum penalties are set out in the table above. All of these offences are summary offences (section 5(2) of the Criminal Procedure Act 1921 (SA)), heard in the Magistrates Court, and a prosecution must be started within 2 years (section 52(1)(b)). None of sections 17, 17A and 17AB fixes an expiation fee.
A trespass charge can be resolved without a conviction. If the court proposes to impose a fine or community service, it may do so without recording a conviction where the defendant is unlikely to reoffend and good reason exists, having regard to character, antecedents, age or condition, the trifling nature of the offence, or other extenuating circumstances (section 24 of the Sentencing Act 2017 (SA)).
In MacDonald v Police [2011] SASC 52, a young man pleaded guilty to a section 17A trespass that was a spontaneous prank, along with a theft of clothing that was promptly returned. Doyle CJ took into account the absence of force or threats, his cooperation, his employment and an employer’s letter not put to the Magistrate, set aside the conviction and left the 80 hours of community service in place ([15] to [16], [19] to [22]). The case was decided under the former sentencing Act, whose test for not recording a conviction was in materially the same terms.
How similar cases tend to play out
Three illustrations of how these sections apply to ordinary facts. They are not predictions. Every case turns on its evidence, the person’s record and the court.
Lower range. Two teenagers climb onto the roof of a closed school on a weekend to take photos and leave when a neighbour shouts at them. They are charged under section 17(1) without lawful excuse. The prosecution must prove more than a civil trespass (Rudloff at [18]), and if it does, a penalty without conviction is a realistic aim (Lee at [2]).
Middle range. A man in a dispute with a business refuses to leave its office when the manager asks him to, and police are called. He leaves with police, then comes back an hour later. Under section 17A, the return within 24 hours is the offence, and a belief that he was entitled to come back does not help once he was clearly told to stay away (Slobodian at [22], [49]).
Upper range. Police find a man at night in the yard of a closed business with tools and gloves, beside a forced door. Serious criminal trespass may be charged if entry to a building is alleged, and if not, section 17(1) for an unlawful purpose carries up to 2 years where the purpose was theft (section 17(1); Pavy at [46] to [47]).
How we defend trespass charges
Trespass charges can turn on the element that distinguishes a crime from a civil wrong. We test whether the prosecution can prove more than a lack of permission, and whether the purpose it alleges is supported by evidence.
| Stage | What happens | What we do |
|---|---|---|
| Arrest or report | Police arrest or report the person, sometimes with damage, theft or possession charges. | Advise on the interview, especially about the purpose for being there. |
| Disclosure | The prosecution provides statements, footage and photographs. | Identify what the evidence shows about purpose, permission and any request to leave. |
| Charge review | The charge may be section 17, 17A or serious criminal trespass. | Test whether the right section was charged and every element can be proved. |
| Negotiation | Charges can be withdrawn, reduced or substituted. | Seek withdrawal, or a section 17A or 17 charge in place of a more serious one. |
| Hearing or sentence | A contested hearing in the Magistrates Court, or a sentence on a plea. | Run the defence, or seek a penalty without conviction where section 24 applies. |
We cannot promise a particular result, and no lawyer can. We can make sure the prosecution proves the element that makes a trespass a crime.
Every hour matters. Book a same-day free 30-minute consultation, or call (08) 7094 2021 now.
Unlawfully on premises case law
These are the South Australian decisions this guide relies on. The case notes state what each court decided.
| Case | Court | Principle | Pinpoint |
|---|---|---|---|
| Police v Rudloff [2018] SASC 101 | Supreme Court | Without lawful excuse requires more than a civil trespass; complaint dismissed | [18] to [20], [22], [24] to [25] |
| Lee & Rulfs v Police [2009] SASC 263 | Supreme Court | Parkour on shop roofs at night: charge proved, no conviction recorded | [2] to [4], [16] to [17] |
| Pavy v Police [2002] SASC 293 | Supreme Court | The prosecution must identify the unlawful purpose; serious example; sentence upheld | [1] to [3], [37] to [38], [46] to [48] |
| Police v Slobodian [2008] SASC 69 | Supreme Court | Section 17A punishes failing to leave or returning; fault element; no claim of right | [3], [22], [38], [49] |
| King v Police [2007] SASC 93 | Supreme Court | Interfering with the occupier's right to manage its premises; not limited to squatters | [16] to [19], [26] to [27] |
| MacDonald v Police [2011] SASC 52 | Supreme Court | Section 17A prank: conviction set aside, community service left in place | [1], [15] to [16], [19] to [22] |
Case notes
Police v Rudloff [2018] SASC 101
A man was convicted under section 17(1) of being on his neighbour’s riverfront block without lawful excuse. Peek J held that the prosecution must prove the trespass so transcended the infringement of a civil right that it called for the criminal law ([18]), that the Magistrate had not adverted to that element ([22]), and that the conduct proved did not reach it. The appeal was allowed and the complaint dismissed ([24] to [25]).
Lee & Rulfs v Police [2009] SASC 263
Two men practising parkour on shop roofs at night were found guilty under section 17(1) of being on premises without lawful excuse, without a conviction being recorded, and fined $200 each ([1] to [4]). Nyland J was not persuaded the Magistrate erred in applying the authorities to the facts, including that members of the public were alarmed, and dismissed the appeal ([16] to [17]).
Pavy v Police [2002] SASC 293
The defendant was sentenced to 10 months imprisonment for being on premises for an unlawful purpose, which also activated the balance of his parole. Perry J held the prosecution must identify the purpose alleged and was entitled to identify the one it did, found the sentence within range for a serious example, and dismissed the appeal ([1] to [3], [37], [46] to [48]).
Police v Slobodian [2008] SASC 69
On a police appeal, Gray J held that section 17A does not criminalise the initial trespass but the failure to leave, or a return within 24 hours ([22]), that the fault element is knowledge or recklessness as to being a trespasser ([38]), and that a belief in an entitlement to return gave no claim of right, so a conviction should be recorded ([3], [49]).
King v Police [2007] SASC 93
A man ran a stall on university grounds and refused to remove it or leave. Doyle CJ held that he interfered with the university’s right to manage the use of its premises, that this was not a bare or technical trespass, and that section 17A reaches beyond residential squatting, and dismissed the appeal against conviction ([16] to [19], [26] to [27]).
MacDonald v Police [2011] SASC 52
A young man pleaded guilty to a section 17A trespass and a theft arising from a prank. Doyle CJ held the Magistrate erred in recording a conviction, set it aside, and left the community service order in place ([15] to [16], [19] to [22]).
Frequently asked questions
Is trespassing a crime in SA?
Being on someone’s land or premises without permission is not automatically a crime. It becomes one under section 17 of the Summary Offences Act 1953 (SA) if the person is there for an unlawful purpose, or without lawful excuse in a way that goes beyond a civil wrong, and under section 17A if a trespasser refuses to leave or comes back within 24 hours.
What is the penalty for being unlawfully on premises in SA?
Up to 2 years imprisonment where the unlawful purpose is an offence punishable by 2 years or more, and otherwise $2,500 or 6 months (section 17(1)). Failing to leave when asked carries $2,500 or 6 months (section 17A(1)), with higher penalties for farm premises.
Who has to prove lawful excuse?
For section 17, the prosecution must prove the absence of a lawful excuse (section 17(1a)). It must also prove the trespass went beyond a mere civil wrong and calls for the criminal law.
Can I be charged just for refusing to leave?
Yes, if your presence interfered with the occupier’s enjoyment of the premises, you were asked to leave by an authorised person, and you did not leave forthwith or came back within 24 hours (section 17A(1)).
What does "interfere with the enjoyment of the premises" mean?
More than just being there. In King v Police [2007] SASC 93, setting up a stall on university grounds and refusing to remove it interfered with the university’s right to manage the use of its own premises.
What is the difference between unlawfully on premises and serious criminal trespass?
Serious criminal trespass requires entering or remaining as a trespasser in a building or home not open to the public, intending to commit theft, an offence against the person or a serious property damage offence, and carries up to 10 years or more. Being on premises for an unlawful purpose under section 17 carries up to 2 years.
Is trespassing on a farm treated differently?
Yes. Since 9 July 2020, section 17(a1) and (a2) set higher penalties for primary production premises, including up to $10,000 or 12 months in aggravated circumstances, and compensation can be ordered.
Can police tell me to leave somewhere?
Yes. If an officer believes on reasonable grounds that you are on premises to commit an offence, the officer can order you to leave, and failing to comply is an offence (section 17(2), (3)).
Can I avoid a conviction for trespass?
Possibly. If the court imposes a fine or community service, section 24 of the Sentencing Act 2017 (SA) allows it to do so without recording a conviction where good reason exists, as happened in Lee & Rulfs v Police and MacDonald v Police.
Do I need a lawyer for a trespass charge?
The law does not require one. But the element that turns a trespass into a crime, and the choice between section 17, section 17A and serious criminal trespass, can decide these cases, and we test both on the evidence.
South Australian courts we attend for trespass charges
We defend unlawfully on premises and trespass charges in the Adelaide Magistrates Court and the suburban and regional Magistrates Courts listed below.
Courts we attend
Book a same-day free 30-minute consultation or call (08) 7094 2021.