A charge of using a hire vehicle without the owner’s consent was withdrawn at a pre-trial conference in the Port Augusta Magistrates Court after we showed the prosecution that its own brief did not establish the owner it had named.
Our client was charged with driving or using a motor vehicle without the owner’s consent. If proved, the charge carried a 12 month licence disqualification that the court could not reduce, even without a conviction.
We put the problems in the prosecution case in writing and spoke candidly with the prosecutor the same day. That call produced a pathway to withdrawal, and the charge was withdrawn without a trial.
Outcome at a glance
- Driving or using a motor vehicle without consent (section 86A(1)) withdrawn at the pre-trial conference
- The court permitted the charge to be withdrawn; no trial was required
- No finding of guilt and no conviction
- No licence disqualification
- Our client did not seek costs, as agreed with the prosecution
- Heard in the Port Augusta Magistrates Court
Overview
Our client was a passenger in a hire vehicle in regional South Australia. Police alleged that our client then drove it without the consent of its owner, and charged our client with one count under section 86A(1) of the Criminal Law Consolidation Act 1935 (SA). The charge named the complainant as “the owner” of the vehicle.
We were instructed after the charge had been before the court for about a year, and our client had been on bail throughout. Our review found two problems in the prosecution case. Both came from its own material.
The challenge: the charge and what it carried
Section 86A(1) makes it an offence to drive, use or interfere with a motor vehicle, on a road or elsewhere, without first obtaining the consent of the owner. A first offence carries a maximum penalty of 2 years imprisonment.
The licence consequence is what made the charge serious. If an adult court finds a person guilty, section 86A(2) requires it to disqualify the person from holding or obtaining a driver’s licence for 12 months, whether or not it records a conviction. Under section 86A(4), that disqualification cannot be reduced or mitigated in any way, or replaced with another penalty. A plea of guilty would have meant the full 12 months, even if the court declined to record a conviction.
Absence of the owner’s consent is part of the offence, so the owner matters. Section 86A gives “owner” the meaning it has in the Road Traffic Act 1961 (SA), and the charge tied the prosecution case to one particular person.
Our approach
1. Test the charge against the prosecution’s own brief
The complainant’s own statement recorded that the vehicle belonged to a hire company. Another prosecution witness described it as hired under a rental agreement. The prosecution’s summary of facts did not call the complainant the owner at all; it described him as “the responsible person for the vehicle”. No hire agreement had been served.
We set this out in a letter to the prosecution. We asked it to identify the owner whose consent was required, the part of the statutory definition relied on to make the complainant that owner, the documents relied on, and whether that was the whole of its evidence on the element. We also asked whether the charge would be maintained as framed or amended.
2. Use the prosecution’s own witnesses on state of mind
The served statements also bore on why our client drove. Police had been sent to check on the welfare of people flagging down passing motorists. Independent witnesses described our client asking for help and for the police. On the prosecution’s own account, the driving ended when the vehicle stopped at the first other vehicle it reached.
Every point in the letter came from the prosecution’s own material. We put to the prosecution that there was no reasonable prospect of conviction, and that the public interest did not require the charge to continue when it had been on foot for more than a year and the court’s own record had noted that disclosure was only partial.
3. Speak to the prosecutor, and be candid
We spoke with the prosecutor the same day the letter went in and were candid about the problems we saw in the case. We also raised the statutory defence of sudden or extraordinary emergency, which arose on the prosecution’s own evidence.
The call produced an agreed pathway. The matter would be listed, by consent, for a pre-trial conference, and if the prosecution had not obtained the hire agreement by then, the charge would be withdrawn. Our client would not seek costs if the charge was withdrawn at or before that conference.
4. Confirm the position in writing
We spoke with the prosecutor again in the week of the conference. Before the conference began, we wrote to the prosecutor to record the agreed position and ask whether the charge would be withdrawn that day. The same email confirmed that no application would be made for costs.
The law: the owner and the emergency defence
Under section 5 of the Road Traffic Act, the owner of a vehicle means a sole, joint or part owner, or a person who has possession or use of the vehicle under a credit, hire-purchase, lease or other agreement (except an agreement requiring the vehicle to be registered in someone else’s name), and it includes the registered owner. With a hire vehicle, more than one person can fit that description. Which owner’s consent the charge turns on, and whether the person named fits the definition, will usually depend on the hire documents.
Section 15E of the Criminal Law Consolidation Act provides a defence where a person acts in response to circumstances of sudden or extraordinary emergency, reasonably believes at the time that the emergency exists and that the conduct is the only reasonable way to deal with it, and the conduct is a reasonable response. The emergency need not involve a risk of death or serious harm. If the defence is raised, it is taken to be established unless the prosecution disproves it beyond reasonable doubt. It does not apply to murder and related offences or to any offence prescribed by regulation, and illegal use of a motor vehicle is not one of them.
Outcome
The prosecution withdrew the charge at the pre-trial conference in the Port Augusta Magistrates Court, and the court permitted it to be withdrawn. There was no finding of guilt and no conviction, so the 12 month disqualification under section 86A(2) never arose. The matter ended without a trial, and our client did not seek costs.
Key takeaways
- The owner’s consent is an element of illegal use of a motor vehicle, and with a hire vehicle, who the owner is can be a technical question. The Road Traffic Act definition can reach more than one person, so the owner named in the charge has to be tested against the hire documents and the rest of the brief.
- A finding of guilt under section 86A brings a 12 month licence disqualification that cannot be reduced, even without a conviction. That makes the decision to contest the charge more important than the maximum penalty suggests.
- A defence can arise on the prosecution’s own evidence. Once the emergency defence in section 15E is raised, the prosecution must disprove it beyond reasonable doubt.
- A clear condition for withdrawal can end a case early. Here the condition was tied to the one document the prosecution needed on ownership, and our client’s undertaking not to seek costs was limited to withdrawal at or before the pre-trial conference.
Related criminal results and guides
- Police pursuit charge withdrawn: case study
- Assault charge against a security guard withdrawn: case study
- Criminal defence lawyers Adelaide
- Traffic lawyers Adelaide
Speak with Talon Legal about illegal use of a motor vehicle charges
If you have been charged with driving or using a motor vehicle without the owner’s consent, get advice before you enter a plea. Book a same-day free 30-minute consultation or call (08) 7094 2021 to speak with a senior criminal lawyer, or read more on our Criminal Defence Lawyers Adelaide page and our Port Augusta Magistrates Court page.
This case study describes one matter. Every case turns on its own facts, and past results do not guarantee a similar outcome.
